Course Introduction
The OECD DAC Evaluation Criteria Application in Development Cooperation Training Course equips participants with the knowledge and practical skills needed to apply internationally recognised evaluation criteria to development policies, programmes, projects, and partnerships. The course explores how evaluators can assess the relevance, coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, impact, and sustainability of development interventions while producing credible findings that support accountability, organisational learning, and better decision-making. Participants will learn to translate the six criteria into evaluation questions, analytical frameworks, evidence requirements, and practical assessment procedures suited to different development contexts and stakeholder needs.
The training introduces the conceptual foundations of the six OECD Development Assistance Committee evaluation criteria and explains how they complement one another in assessing the merit and worth of an intervention. Participants will examine how relevance considers alignment with stakeholder needs and priorities, coherence assesses compatibility with other interventions and policies, effectiveness examines achievement of objectives, efficiency assesses the use of resources, impact explores broader and more significant changes, and sustainability considers the continuation of net benefits. Particular attention is given to understanding the intended meaning of each criterion, avoiding conceptual overlap, and ensuring that evaluation judgements are grounded in appropriate evidence rather than assumptions or predetermined conclusions.
A major component of the course focuses on translating evaluation criteria into clear, answerable evaluation questions and selecting suitable methods for investigating them. Participants will learn to develop evaluation matrices, identify appropriate indicators and qualitative lines of inquiry, establish evidence requirements, and determine how different data sources can support credible judgements. The training examines mixed-methods approaches, document reviews, interviews, focus group discussions, surveys, outcome analysis, contribution analysis, case studies, and comparative assessment. Participants will also explore how evaluation scope, available resources, intervention complexity, data quality, and stakeholder expectations influence the selection of methods and the depth of analysis under each criterion.
The course addresses the practical challenges of evaluating development cooperation interventions involving multiple institutions, funding partners, implementing agencies, beneficiary groups, and policy environments. Participants will examine how to assess coordination, complementarity, duplication, institutional alignment, resource allocation, implementation delays, unintended effects, and the factors that influence the achievement of results. The training also considers the importance of examining differences in outcomes across gender, age, disability, geographic location, socioeconomic status, and other relevant characteristics. Participants will learn to investigate whose needs are addressed, who benefits, who may be excluded, and how contextual changes influence the relevance, effectiveness, and sustainability of interventions.
Strong evaluation practice requires transparent reasoning, appropriate methodological choices, and careful communication of uncertainty and limitations. Participants will learn how to triangulate evidence, distinguish findings from interpretations, assess the strength of supporting information, and develop balanced evaluative judgements against each criterion. The course examines common weaknesses such as treating the criteria as a rigid checklist, relying exclusively on output indicators, equating expenditure with efficiency, confusing impact with effectiveness, or assuming that planned benefits will automatically continue after project closure. Participants will practise documenting evidence gaps, explaining methodological limitations, managing conflicting stakeholder perspectives, and formulating practical recommendations that respond to the findings.
By the end of the training, participants will be better prepared to design and manage evaluations that apply the OECD DAC criteria consistently, thoughtfully, and proportionately. They will understand how to align the criteria with the evaluation purpose, develop a defensible evaluation design, collect and analyse relevant evidence, formulate transparent conclusions, and communicate actionable recommendations to decision-makers and affected stakeholders. The course promotes ethical practice, inclusion, independence where required, stakeholder participation, and the responsible use of evaluation findings. These competencies can strengthen development cooperation accountability, improve programme design and implementation, and support more informed decisions about future policies, investments, and partnerships.
Duration
5 days
Who Should Attend
-
Monitoring and evaluation specialists responsible for assessing development policies, programmes, projects, and partnerships.
-
Development cooperation officers managing evaluations commissioned by bilateral and multilateral agencies.
-
Government officials responsible for planning, monitoring, and evaluating development initiatives.
-
Evaluation managers designing terms of reference, evaluation questions, and assessment frameworks.
-
Independent evaluators and consultants conducting programme, project, thematic, and strategic evaluations.
-
Results-based management specialists linking intervention objectives with measurable outcomes and evaluation evidence.
-
Programme managers seeking to use evaluation findings to improve implementation and organisational performance.
-
Staff of international development organisations responsible for accountability, learning, and performance assessment.
-
NGO and civil society professionals evaluating community development and humanitarian interventions.
-
Donor agency officers assessing the relevance, effectiveness, and sustainability of funded programmes.
-
Research professionals applying mixed-methods approaches to development cooperation evaluation.
-
Public policy analysts examining policy coherence and the contribution of development interventions to wider goals.
-
Gender equality and social inclusion specialists assessing differentiated outcomes and equitable access to benefits.
-
Financial and performance analysts examining resource use, implementation efficiency, and value for money.
-
Climate and environmental programme specialists assessing mitigation, adaptation, and sustainable development interventions.
-
Capacity development professionals evaluating institutional strengthening and organisational change.
-
Project coordinators preparing evaluations for programme completion, extension, redesign, or scale-up decisions.
-
Development partners and technical advisers supporting evaluation quality assurance and evidence-informed decision-making.
Course Objectives
By the end of this course, participants will be able to:
-
Explain the definitions, purposes, and guiding principles of the six OECD DAC evaluation criteria and their application to development cooperation interventions.
-
Translate relevance, coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, impact, and sustainability into clear evaluation questions aligned with the intervention's objectives and evaluation purpose.
-
Develop evaluation matrices that connect criteria, analytical questions, evidence sources, data collection methods, and standards for making evaluative judgements.
-
Select appropriate qualitative, quantitative, and mixed-methods approaches for investigating development intervention performance and results.
-
Assess alignment with beneficiary needs, national priorities, institutional policies, and other interventions while identifying complementarities, inconsistencies, and duplication.
-
Examine achievement of objectives, resource use, implementation timeliness, broader effects, and continuation of benefits using credible and context-sensitive evidence.
-
Apply data triangulation, contribution analysis, comparative assessment, and stakeholder consultation to strengthen the credibility of evaluation findings.
-
Incorporate gender equality, disability inclusion, equity, human rights, and the principle of leaving no one behind into evaluation design and analysis.
-
Prepare balanced evaluation conclusions and actionable recommendations that address evidence gaps, methodological limitations, unintended effects, and implementation constraints.
-
Use OECD DAC criteria to strengthen evaluation reports, quality assurance, organisational learning, accountability, and evidence-informed development cooperation decisions.
Comprehensive Course Outline
Module 1: Foundations of OECD DAC Evaluation Criteria
-
Understanding the purpose and evolution of the OECD DAC evaluation criteria in international development cooperation.
-
Examining the six criteria and their role in assessing the merit and worth of policies, programmes, projects, and strategies.
-
Distinguishing evaluation criteria from evaluation methods, indicators, standards, and performance monitoring frameworks.
-
Applying the principles of thoughtful, context-sensitive evaluation according to purpose, stakeholder needs, and intended use.
Module 2: Evaluation Planning and Criteria Selection
-
Defining the evaluation purpose, scope, intended users, key decisions, and accountability or learning requirements.
-
Selecting and prioritising criteria according to intervention characteristics, evaluation questions, available evidence, and resource constraints.
-
Developing evaluation terms of reference that establish clear questions, methodological expectations, responsibilities, and deliverables.
-
Preparing evaluation matrices that connect each criterion with analytical questions, evidence sources, and proposed methods.
Module 3: Applying the Relevance Criterion
-
Assessing how intervention objectives and design respond to beneficiary needs, national priorities, and institutional commitments.
-
Examining the suitability of intervention design in relation to economic, social, environmental, political, and capacity conditions.
-
Investigating how changing circumstances affect intervention relevance and the need for adaptation during implementation.
-
Analysing differences among stakeholder priorities and identifying whose needs are addressed or insufficiently represented.
Module 4: Applying the Coherence Criterion
-
Assessing the compatibility of an intervention with other policies, programmes, institutional strategies, and international commitments.
-
Examining internal coherence across programmes and policies implemented by the same organisation or government.
-
Investigating external coherence through coordination, complementarity, harmonisation, and collaboration with other development actors.
-
Identifying conflicting objectives, overlapping activities, duplication, and opportunities for greater collective development impact.
Module 5: Applying the Effectiveness Criterion
-
Assessing the extent to which intended outputs, outcomes, and objectives have been achieved or are expected to be achieved.
-
Comparing actual results with planned targets and investigating the factors contributing to achievement or underperformance.
-
Examining differences in results across beneficiary groups, geographic areas, and other relevant population characteristics.
-
Identifying unintended positive and negative effects and assessing the evidence supporting explanations of observed results.
Module 6: Applying the Efficiency Criterion
-
Examining how financial, human, technical, natural, and time resources are converted into outputs, outcomes, and wider results.
-
Assessing economic efficiency, operational performance, implementation timeliness, and the causes of resource waste or delays.
-
Comparing feasible alternatives that could achieve comparable results while accounting for context, quality, and distributional considerations.
-
Integrating expenditure analysis, implementation records, procurement information, and outcome evidence to support efficiency judgements.
Module 7: Applying the Impact Criterion
-
Examining significant higher-level changes in social, economic, institutional, environmental, and human development outcomes.
-
Investigating intended and unintended effects, indirect consequences, transformative change, and differences in impact across groups.
-
Applying contribution analysis, theory-based evaluation, comparative methods, and other suitable approaches to assess how change occurred.
-
Distinguishing observed changes from demonstrated causal effects and documenting alternative explanations and evidentiary limitations.
Module 8: Applying the Sustainability Criterion
-
Assessing the extent to which net benefits continue or are likely to continue after external support or project funding ends.
-
Examining financial, economic, social, environmental, and institutional conditions that influence the continuation of benefits.
-
Analysing ownership, local capacity, maintenance arrangements, financing prospects, resilience, and risks to long-term results.
-
Identifying trade-offs and contextual changes that may strengthen or undermine the sustainability of development outcomes.
Module 9: Evidence Analysis, Inclusion, and Evaluation Judgements
-
Triangulating quantitative data, qualitative evidence, stakeholder perspectives, administrative records, and independent research findings.
-
Integrating gender equality, disability inclusion, equity, human rights, and the principle of leaving no one behind into evaluation analysis.
-
Developing transparent evaluative judgements while distinguishing verified findings, interpretations, assumptions, and methodological limitations.
-
Addressing conflicting evidence, stakeholder power dynamics, ethical considerations, and risks of bias in evaluation conclusions.
Module 10: Evaluation Reporting, Recommendations, and Practical Application
-
Structuring evaluation reports to present findings, conclusions, recommendations, and evidence under the relevant DAC criteria.
-
Developing practical recommendations that respond to identified weaknesses, implementation opportunities, and stakeholder priorities.
-
Preparing a complete evaluation matrix and applying the six criteria to a realistic development cooperation case study.
-
Establishing quality assurance, management response, dissemination, and follow-up arrangements to support learning and accountability.
Training Approach
This course will be delivered by our skilled trainers who have vast knowledge and experience as expert professionals in the fields. The course is taught in English and through a mix of theory, practical activities, group discussion and case studies. Course manuals and additional training materials will be provided to the participants upon completion of the training.
Tailor-Made Course
This course can also be tailor-made to meet organization requirement. For further inquiries, please contact us on: Email: training@upskilldevelopment.com Tel: +254 721 331 808
Training Venue
The training will be held at our Upskill Training Centre. We also offer training for a group (at a discount of 10% to 50%) at requested location all over the world. The Onsite course fee covers the course tuition, training materials, two break refreshments, buffet lunch, airport transfers, Upskill gift package, and guided tour.
Visa application, travel expenses, dinners, accommodation, insurance, and other personal expenses are catered by the participant
Certification
Participants will be issued with Upskill certificate upon completion of this course.
Airport Pickup and Accommodation
Airport pickup and accommodation is arranged upon request. For booking contact our Training Coordinator through Email: training@upskilldevelopment.com, +254 721 331 808
Terms of Payment:
Unless otherwise agreed between the two parties’ payment of the course fee should be done 3 working days before commencement of the training so as to enable us to prepare better.








